Core topics batch 1: Applying evals

PR #18047 adds nine Applying topics as structured core policies. The same eval rows and synthetic seed ran on origin/main (8f67ad1b) and on this branch (8d788024). Subscription runner, claude-sonnet-4-6. Synthetic eval companies only.

Result

The 11 Applying rows: 11 of 11 fail on main, 11 of 11 pass on the branch. The other 63 rows: 63 pass on main and 63 on the branch. Totals: main 63/74, branch 74/74.

Applying roworigin/mainBranch
APPLICATION DOCUMENTS, sms — photo ID, bank statements and an offer letter, from the Application documents answerFAILPASS
INCOME REQUIREMENT, sms — 2.5 times the rent, from the company's answerFAILPASS
INCOME REQUIREMENT, voice — 2.5 times the rentFAILPASS
INCOME REQUIREMENT, building override, sms — Sample Row asks 3 times the rent, whatever the company asksFAILPASS
SCREENING CRITERIA, sms — credit, rental history and no evictions in the last 4 yearsFAILPASS
APPLICATION DECISION TIME, sms — 3 to 5 business daysFAILPASS
HOUSING VOUCHERS, sms — yes, vouchers are acceptedFAILPASS
CO-SIGNERS, sms — yes, and the guarantor earns 5 times the rent (the note)FAILPASS
PORTABLE SCREENING, sms — no, the applicant's own report is not acceptedFAILPASS
OCCUPANCY LIMIT, sms — up to 3 people per bedroomFAILPASS
HOLDING A UNIT, sms — a $200 holding deposit holds it for 5 daysFAILPASS
The other 63 rows, main against branch
Roworigin/mainBranch
PETS, sms — a 65 lb dog: the 50 lb limit and manager approval, from the one Pets answerPASSPASS
PETS, voice — a 65 lb dog: the 50 lb limit and manager approvalPASSPASS
PETS follow-up, sms — after 'cats and dogs are welcome': how many and the monthly chargePASSPASS
PETS, building override, sms — Sample Row allows no pets, whatever the company allowsPASSPASS
PETS, building override, voice — no pets at Sample RowPASSPASS
PETS, field-level (1c-1), sms — the company says no pets; Mock Gardens' older record holds only a weight limit, so it is still no petsPASSPASS
PETS, one statement (1c-1), sms — Fixture Commons: the older 'up to three' entry was folded into the Pets answer (up to 2); Clara states 2 onlyPASSPASS
LEASE LENGTHS, sms — 6 or 12 months, from the Lease lengths answerPASSPASS
MONTH-TO-MONTH, voice — offered, 60 days noticePASSPASS
NOTICE TO MOVE OUT, sms — 45 days at the end of a fixed-term leasePASSPASS
EARLY TERMINATION, sms — allowed: 2 months of rent and 60 days noticePASSPASS
SMOKING, sms — not inside; outside only in the designated area by the side gatePASSPASS
SMOKING, building override, sms — Sample Row allows no smoking outside eitherPASSPASS
MONTH-TO-MONTH, older building record, sms — Placeholder Flats: its $75 MTM fee, and the company's 60 days noticePASSPASS
EARLY TERMINATION, older building record, sms — Placeholder Flats: 3x monthly rent (never the company's 2 months), the company's 60 days noticePASSPASS
EARLY TERMINATION, building's own answer over its older record, sms — Stub Lofts: 1 month of rent, never the older 3xPASSPASS
UTILITIES, sms — water, sewer and trash included; residents pay electricity and gasPASSPASS
UTILITIES, older building record, sms — Placeholder Flats: residents pay all (regression guard)PASSPASS
PARKING, sms — included, an assigned spotPASSPASS
PARKING, older building record, sms — Placeholder Flats: guest parking from the company's answerPASSPASS
PARKING, building's own answer over its older record, sms — Stub Lofts: $120 a month, never the older $90PASSPASS
PARKING, enrolled building, sms — Fixture Yards: its own $120, never the lease policy's $90 (the lease grounding points at the topic)PASSPASS
PARKING, enrolled building, voice — Fixture Yards: $120, never $90PASSPASS
UTILITIES, enrolled building, sms — Fixture Yards: electricity and gas from the topic, no 'not on file' deflectionPASSPASS
UTILITIES, enrolled building, voice — Fixture Yards: electricity and gas, no deflectionPASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, sms — required, $100,000 minimum coveragePASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, older pricing record, sms — Placeholder Flats: $300,000, never the company's $100,000 (regression guard)PASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, lease policy, sms — Sample Annex: $250,000 and the named additional interest, never the company's $100,000PASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, building's own answer over its lease policy, sms — Mock Towers: $200,000 (never $250,000), the additional interest still namedPASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, building's own answer over its pricing record, sms — Stub Lofts: $150,000 (never $300,000) and the record's $15 admin feePASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, building's own answer over its lease policy, voice — Mock Towers: $200,000 only (the lease grounding points at the topic)PASSPASS
RENTER'S INSURANCE, building's own 'not required' over its lease policy, sms — Demo Lofts: not required, no minimum, no in-force datePASSPASS
QUIET HOURS, sms — 10pm to 7amPASSPASS
STORAGE, sms — storage available, $40 a monthPASSPASS
STORAGE, older building record, sms — Placeholder Flats: its $55 fee, never the company's $40PASSPASS
SUBLETTING, sms — only with approvalPASSPASS
GUESTS, voice — 14 nights before a guest counts as an occupantPASSPASS
ALTERATIONS, sms — painting with written approval; small nail holes are finePASSPASS
PACKAGES, voice — deliveries go to the package lockersPASSPASS
AMENITIES, sms — Example Court: a gym, from the company's Amenities answerPASSPASS
LAUNDRY, voice — Sample Lofts: in-unit, its own answer; the scraped list's 'not on file' negative is suppressedPASSPASS
LAUNDRY, sms — Sample Lofts: in-unit laundry from its own answerPASSPASS
AMENITIES, older scraped list, sms — Sample Lofts: the list (pool, clubroom) wins; the company's 'Gym' is not claimed (regression guard)PASSPASS
LAUNDRY, older record, sms — Mock Point: shared, its own answer, never the older in-unit flagPASSPASS
AMENITIES, own list without a gym, sms — Stub Gardens: still a gym (own answers state, never remove scraped items)PASSPASS
PARKING, a home's own listing over the company's answer, sms — Mock Homes: the two-car garage, never the company's $75PASSPASS
PARKING, a home's own listing over the company's answer, voice — Mock Homes: the two-car garage, never $75PASSPASS
PARKING, a home's own listing with no conflict, sms — Demo Homes: its covered spot, and the company's $75 is not quoted for this homePASSPASS
CUSTOM POLICY, sms — pool hours from a titled custom entry (regression guard)PASSPASS
NOTHING SET, sms — no invented smoking or pet rule; the team confirms (regression guard)PASSPASS
ENTRY NOTICE, sms — notice before someone enters: 48 hours, from the topicPASSPASS
MOVE-IN INSPECTION, sms — is there a move-in checklist: yes, back within 5 daysPASSPASS
DEPOSIT RETURN, sms — how soon the deposit comes back: 21 daysPASSPASS
DEPOSIT RETURN, building override, sms — Sample Row returns deposits within 14 daysPASSPASS
DEPOSIT RETURN, nothing set, sms — no timeline invented (regression guard, passes both sides)PASSPASS
CLEANING AND KEY RETURN, sms — what to do on the last day: keys in the office drop box by noonPASSPASS
MOVE-OUT INSPECTION, sms — is there a walk-through: yes, on the last dayPASSPASS
TOUR TYPE, sms — asked to tour alone with a lockbox at a building with self-guided off: an agent shows it, no self-guided offerPASSPASS
TOUR TYPE, self-guided building, sms — at a building switched on for self-guided, the company's 'An agent shows it' never becomes a promise that someone meets themPASSPASS
KEY HANDOFF, sms — how keys work on move-in day: a smart lock code, from the topicPASSPASS
KEY HANDOFF, voice — keys on move-in day: a smart lock codePASSPASS
AFTER APPROVAL, sms — what happens once approved: sign within 72 hours, then the depositPASSPASS
MAINTENANCE REQUESTS, sms — how repairs are requested once living there: the resident portal or a textPASSPASS
What Clara said on each Applying row, main against branch

APPLICATION DOCUMENTS, sms — photo ID, bank statements and an offer letter, from the Application documents answer
Main: I don't have the specific document checklist on file — I'll check with the leasing team and get back to you on that. Also, we don't have an application link on file, so I'll have the team send that your way too. I'll check with the leasing team and get back to you shortly!
Branch: You'll need a photo ID, bank statements, and an offer letter. The application usually takes 3 to 5 business days to process. I don't have an application link on file — I'll check with the leasing team and get back to you on how to submit it.

INCOME REQUIREMENT, sms — 2.5 times the rent, from the company's answer
Main: Income and credit are reviewed together as part of the full application — we don't have set minimums we share up front. Our leasing team looks at the whole picture once you apply. Want to come take a look at the 2-bedroom?
Branch: The income requirement is 2.5 times the monthly rent. So once you know the exact rent on the 2-bedroom, multiply by 2.5 and that's the minimum. Want me to pull up current pricing and availability?

INCOME REQUIREMENT, voice — 2.5 times the rent
Main: Income, credit, and background are all reviewed together as part of the application — the leasing team evaluates the full picture, so there's no single threshold I can quote upfront. Would you like to come see the two-bedroom, or do you have other questions about it?
Branch: The minimum income requirement is two and a half times the monthly rent. For a two-bedroom, that works out against whichever unit's rent you're looking at — the two-bedrooms here run nineteen hundred to twenty-one fifty a month, so you'd want to factor against that range. Want to come see one? I've got tomorrow at two or four-thirty, or Saturday at eleven.

INCOME REQUIREMENT, building override, sms — Sample Row asks 3 times the rent, whatever the company asks
Main: Income, credit, and rental history are all reviewed as part of the application itself — we don't pre-screen up front. Once you apply, the leasing team evaluates your full profile. Want to see what's available and come take a look?
Branch: The minimum income requirement is 3 times the monthly rent. Are you looking for a specific unit size so I can give you the exact number?

SCREENING CRITERIA, sms — credit, rental history and no evictions in the last 4 years
Main: The application reviews credit history, rental history, and a background check. Income, credit, and rental history are all considered together as part of your full profile. For anything specific to your situation — like how a particular factor might be weighed — our leasing team handles that directly. Want to come take a look at a unit first?
Branch: We check credit, rental history, and evictions — specifically no evictions in the last 4 years. Decisions usually come back within 3 to 5 business days. You'll also need a photo ID, bank statements, and an offer letter to apply. Want to come take a look at the place?

APPLICATION DECISION TIME, sms — 3 to 5 business days
Main: I don't have a set turnaround on file for application reviews. I'll check with the leasing team and get back to you on that.
Branch: Usually 3 to 5 business days. You'll hear back once the review is complete!

HOUSING VOUCHERS, sms — yes, vouchers are accepted
Main: Thanks for letting me know about the Section 8 voucher — that's something our leasing team handles directly as part of the application, so I'll have them confirm the details with you.
Branch: Yes — housing choice vouchers are accepted as a source of income as part of the application here. Would you like to know more about available units or the application process?

CO-SIGNERS, sms — yes, and the guarantor earns 5 times the rent (the note)
Main: Co-signers are something our leasing team handles as part of the application process. I'll check with them and get back to you on the specifics for your situation. In the meantime, want to see what's available? I can pull up units and set up a tour.
Branch: Yes! Co-signers and guarantors are accepted here. Your parent would just need to earn 5 times the monthly rent to qualify as a guarantor. Want to take a look at what's available?

PORTABLE SCREENING, sms — no, the applicant's own report is not accepted
Main: That's something our leasing team handles directly — whether a third-party report is accepted is their call, not mine. I'll check with them and get back to you. In the meantime, do you have any questions about the units or the property?
Branch: Unfortunately, Example Court doesn't accept portable screening reports — you'd need to go through their application process directly. I don't have an application link on file, so let me check with the team and get that to you.

OCCUPANCY LIMIT, sms — up to 3 people per bedroom
Main: The published occupancy standard is 2 people per bedroom, so a 2-bedroom would typically cover up to 4 occupants. For a family of five, I'd recommend checking with the leasing team — they can confirm whether that works for your household. Want to come take a look at the 2-bedroom? I can get you in for a tour.
Branch: The occupancy limit is 3 people per bedroom, so a 2-bedroom can accommodate up to 6 people — your family of five would fit just fine! Want to come take a look? I can check what tour times are available.

HOLDING A UNIT, sms — a $200 holding deposit holds it for 5 days
Main: Holding a specific unit is something our leasing team handles directly — I don't have a holding deposit amount on file. I'll check with them and get back to you on that. In the meantime, want to go ahead and tour so you're first in line?
Branch: Yes! There's a $200 holding deposit that holds a unit for 5 days while you pull your paperwork together. Want me to get you set up with the application to kick things off?

One assertion narrowed

On the first branch run, the portable screening row failed on its own over-broad check. Clara gave the right policy and then offered to check on the application link. The hedge check now matches only hedging about the policy ("check whether" or "check if").

PropFlow Docs